
Was having a conversation Saturday with my little sis from another mother Jordana in which we touched on the
jacked up news coverage of Cemia's death and the AP Stylebook guidelines for covering trans people.
We noted how the Cleveland
Plain Dealer seems to have adopted
flipping the journalistic middle finger at the Cleveland trans community in their Cemia Dove Acoff coverage and also talked about the disrespectful reporting incidents in New York with
Lorena Escalera and Los Angeles with
Cassidy Vickers that pissed off people in those trans communities as well.
By the way, here's what the AP Stylebook currently states about covering transpeople .
transgender-Use the pronoun preferred
by the individuals who have acquired the physical characteristics of the
opposite sex or present themselves in a way that does not correspond
with their sex at birth.
If that preference is not expressed, use the pronoun consistent with the way the individuals live publicly.
Fortunately I'm seeing a lot less instances of media outlets putting a trans persons chosen or new name in quotation marks. But with the way some of the media outlets have been backsliding on or straight up ignoring the AP Stylebook guidelines lately, I won't be surprised to see that odious news article tendency make a comeback.
What I and a lot of transpeople are also concerned about is seeing in far too many stories about us lately adding the line 'born as ___________' or 'legal name is __________'.
I'm proposing that since many transpeople find this problematic, another line be added to the AP Stylebook guidelines or the NGLJA and GLAAD stylebooks that state that we find this problematic and they not do it.
You already know by stating the person is transgender is sufficient enough for the average reader of your story to know that the person you're writing about wasn't born with the gender characteristics they currently have. So why add the birth name of that person unless you're deliberately trying to be disrespectful or salacious?
I also can't stress this point enough that transpeople consider you using the name that matches their current gender presentation
as a sign of respect of their lives.
Are we not worthy of the
same media respect that a cis person gets?