His crime was despite leading the Wildcats to four Elite Eights and six Sweet 16s, five SEC regular-season championships, five SEC Tournament crowns, seven SEC East division titles, having a 52-18 record in March, a 35-4 record en route to the school’s seventh NCAA Championship in 1998, leading the Cats in 2003 to a 32-4 record, a perfect 16-0 regular-season SEC record and a 19-0 sweep of league opponents, he wasn't winning enough championships to satisfy the impossibly high and unrealistic standards of UK basketball fans in a 21st century college b-ball landscape of increasing parity.
In that post I made this prediction about what would happen to UK's basketball program if they forced Tubby out.
So what would happen if the haters got their wish and Tubby got canned? First of all a coach with Tubby's pedigree wouldn't be unemployed long. He'd be coaching somewhere else before the next season started. UK would get lambasted in the national press and by the college coaching fraternity for doing so.
They would instantly cede basketball supremacy in the state to Louisville. The negative fallout from the firing would ensure that many elite and top-tier African-American players both inside and outside the state would bypass Lexington and play at U of L or elsewhere for at least five to ten years. UK will also have a tough time attracting the same type of high quality coach especially after his fellow coaches watched him get shabbily treated by a segment of the UK fan base.
I wrote a subsequent post called 'Mission Accomplished?' after the UK Tubby haters gleefully posted a George W. Bush style 'Mission Accomplished' picture on their 'Fire Tubby' websites in the wake of his resignation and subsequent hiring by Minnesota.
I had this to say about Billy Gillispie being hired by UK to replace him after several high profile coaches such as Michigan State's Tom Izzo, Texas' Rick Barnes and Florida's Billy Donovan, the coach UK faithful lusted after and desperately wanted, all turned down the UK head coaching position, thus fulfilling one of the prediction I laid out in the 'Quit Hatin' On Tubby post.
Gillispie left Texas A&M to come here and I hope he realizes what he's gotten himself into. He could've stayed at A&M, built that program into a national power to compete and beat the hated Longhorns and had the undying love and devotion of Aggies worldwide. I wonder how long a honeymoon he'll have if he doesn't meet the stress inducing expectations of the UK faithful.
Turns out it lasted until November 6, 2007, the night the then Number 20 ranked Wildcats suffered an embarrassing 84-68 home loss to Gardner-Webb.
UK is on the verge of missing the NCAA tournament for the first time since 1991 and losing its cachet as the winningest college basketball team to North Carolina. If that happens, the latest chapter of 'As Rupp Arena Turns' could get ugly.
But while we wait to see how this basketball drama plays out, let's check out the predictions I made in the wake of Tubby's departure.
*Coaching somewhere else before the next season started- Check
*UK lambasted in the national press for forcing Tubby out- Check
*Cede basketball supremacy in Kentucky to U of L-Check
*Elite level African-American ballers in Kentucky and elsewhere declining to play there and heading to Louisville for five to ten years- so far on target*
*UK program having tough time attracting elite level B-ball coach in wake of Tubby dissing-Check
In the meantime, Tubby is getting mad love in the Land of 10,000 Lakes for taking a Minnesota program that went 9-20 the year before he arrived to a 20 win NIT tournament appearance in his first year.
For somebody that some UK fans loudly claimed couldn't recruit, not only set the dominos in place before he left Lexington for the Cats to get Patrick Patterson, but grabbed a Top 20 class for the Golden Gophers that included Ralph Sampson III, the son of former NBA baller Ralph Sampson.
With their as of this writing 21-8 record (the 16th straight year Tubby's coached a 20 win team) Minnesota's poised to return to the NCAA tournament for the first time in a decade.
Tubby's 2008-09 Gophers squad also did something that UK didn't-beat Louisville.
How you like him now?